December 31, 2007
Pros and cons of silver amalgam fillings
There are both pros and cons of silver amalgam fillings, and while most dentists and patients are currently moving to white composite fillings, there are still some great advantages of silver amalgam fillings. Let's take a look at both the pros and cons:
Pros:
1. Money: Silver amalgam fillings are less expensive than other options.
2. Faster: Silver amalgam fillings can be placed much faster than a composite, so if you do not want to be in your dental office all day, this is a great option. Composite fillings, if they are done correctly, take about 60% longer, require special expertise and expensive materials, and are more difficult to place, and so they cost considerably more than silver.
3. Any dentist can do one. General dentists can place amalgam without extra training. Composite requires the use of special bonding technology that many dentists are uncomfortable with, and that is not taught in general dentistry, but requires after school training to be done correctly.
4. Easy to place, and more comfortable for patients. A silver amalgam filling does not require this strict isolation of the tooth. So, if your tooth is in the front or back of the mouth it doesn't matter a whole lot. The proper placement of a white composite filling requires that the site for the filling be kept totally isolated from saliva while it is being placed. In the very back of the mouth, on some patients, it is difficult to keep the tooth isolated for the duration of the procedure. This can also be uncomfortable for some patients.
5. Strong. The filling by itself is a stronger material than white composite.
6. History. Silver fillings have a long history of use, thus some feel that they are more tried and tested, dentists likely have tons and tons of experience placing them, and the technique is pretty much whittled down to a T as it has been used for so long.
7. Hold up better. Silver amalgam fillings do not deteriorate with alcohol consumption, at least not nearly as fast as composite fillings. Composite fillings can be seriously weakened by excessive alcohol consumption. If you have a habit of drinking beverages with high alcohol content (whiskey, etc.) on a daily basis, you may find the composite fillings deteriorating prematurely, but silver amalgam fillings will last.
Cons:
1. Looks. Silver fillings look ugly. Even if it is in your back teeth and molars, silver fillings are not as nice looking as white composite. Most people find this con to be the deciding factor when choosing between silver and white fillings. When fillings that can so closely match tooth color are available, it is difficult to opt for something that stands out so bad.
2. Weakens tooth. While the material itself is stronger, it weakens the surrounding tooth, which in the long run could lead to greater expense as repairing fractured teeth is expensive.
3. Mercury. One of the main reasons people switch from silver amalgam fillings to white composite is white composite is mercury free. Mercury can leach from the filling into your body, can collect in the kidneys etc, and lead to several health issues. So, it is environmentally and physiologically better for you not to have mercury fillings in your mouth.



























